Forgot username ends in Login first

Awesom plugin this Login Redirect. Just what I needed. But I have an issue with redirecting the Forgot username. This should lead to an article on my site though I can't make it happen. With Forgot password and Register this works flawless but when klicking Forgot username I get You have to login first. Settings are:

Forgot Password Component/App - Custom
Custom Redirect Password Menu - Home
Custom Redirect Password to URL

Forgot Username Component/App - Custom
Custom Redirect Username to Menu - Home
Custom Redirect Username to URL

When I disable the plugin and klick on Forgot username I get the default Joomla page to enter my email address so that works as it should work.

My site runs Joomla 2.5.8